Two verdicts, unequal strengths, and one of them has a number attached.
Why the two answers differ in strength
Presence in a zone file is a positive fact: the registry delegated this name. Absence is the absence of a fact, and absences are always weaker — a domain can be registered and missing from the zone, and nothing in the zone can say so.
Measuring the gap against ICANN's own reports
The size of that weakness was not guessed. ICANN publishes monthly registry reports with per-TLD domain counts, and comparing one against the zone gives the gap directly:
| Measure | .com |
|---|---|
| Registered, per ICANN's registry reports | 169,209,254 |
| Present in the zone file | 166,467,808 |
| Registered but absent | 1.62% |
Why a registered domain goes missing
Because delegation and registration are different states. A domain can be registered with no nameservers set at all — freshly bought and not yet configured, or parked in a registrar account with nothing pointing anywhere. A suspended domain may have its delegation pulled while the registration stands. None of those are visible from a file that only records delegation.
The rate is not the same everywhere
Roughly 2.4% in .net and 3.1% in .org, against 1.62% in .com. A probably_free verdict therefore carries about twice the error outside .com as inside it, which is worth knowing before a shortlist is filtered on it.


